A caller wanted a cash prize, so Howard gave him a shot at The Amish Game, explaining that Wolfie had quizzed a man who was raised in the infamously-sheltered Amish community – and if the caller could guess whether or not the guy would correctly answer the questions, he'll take home a $500 cash prize. 3 out of 5 wins.
Abraham Lincoln was born in what state? The caller didn't think the Amish guy would know the answer: "Kentucky?" Howard gave the caller the point anyway, as even he was surprised to learn that Lincoln wasn't born in Illinois. What do the initials FBI stand for? The caller earned a second point when the Amish guy blew it: "Federal Investigation, right?" What profession is Hulk Hogan associated with? The caller again bet against the Amish guy, but lost the point: "Wrestling." What planet is closest to the sun? The caller took the $500 when the Amish guy answered: "The moon? I don't know."