Supermodel Carol Alt (in the past Fred has disputed this classification, however, in light of her recent triumph over cancer, Fred said he was giving her a pass) stopped by to promote her new Playboy pictorial – her first nude shoot ever. Howard asked how Carol reconciled her shoot with her newfound Christianity, so she explained that she wasn't a fanatic: "I just read my Bible in the morning." Carol also said she was capable of miracles herself - she cured herself of cancer with a raw food diet. Howard doubted her story, and eventually Carol admitted: "The only thing I did was [buy] a little time with progesterone."
Carol told a story about being "quasi raped" by "a famous tennis player," saying they went out a couple times and one night he offered to walk her back to her hotel room, where "he attacked me...I was about 18 or 19 years old...maybe I wanted it but not at that time or in that way. He threw me on the bed and ripped my panties off." Carol said he didn't get far: "I'm a feisty New Yorker...he got one right to the groin." Robin wanted more details about the guilty party, but Carol would only say he was foreign.
Howard stopped Carol mid-story and told her he loved how her breasts looked in her Playboy pictorial: "You have the boobs of a 19-year-old." Carol thanked Howard and bragged: "They defy gravity!" Howard told Carol that he also loved her big areolas: "And I don't usually love big areolas, but they're not too dark. What do you think about that?" Carol she wasn't sure: "I don't really think about that." Carol then claimed her Playboy pictures were totally un-retouched.