McEnroe Was the Best She’s Ever Had

June 15, 2011
Photo: The Howard Stern Show

Asked about her time with other famous man in her life, Tatum said sex with John McEnroe was the best she’d ever had: “Hands down. Because he loved me.”

But added that John was a better man today: “I don’t think that John was quite as sensitive as he is now. Like, I think he’s a better man now…”

Out of respect for John’s current wife, Patty Smyth, Tatum later refused to say whether or not she’d take him back.